More Amazement At Statistical Modeling

by Codewiz51 June 05, 2009 12:43

More updates on the Birth Death Model:

Birth Death Adjustment Goosed NFP

Graph of Birth Death model results

Payrolls revised, mistakenly said unemployment rate fell | The Big Picture

What continues to amaze me is that here we have better than expected job loss data, but somehow, the birth/death (B/D) model generated 175K more jobs in May 2009 compared to May 2008. I am always, always, always skeptical of "facts" obtained from simulations and models. Why? I used to do a lot of molecular orbital work. The results were never very good on the whole, although we achieved some successes on a hit or miss basis. Based on my own work, and the work of weathermen predicting rain in my front yard, I am even more skeptical of something called a birth-death model of jobs creation.  (Sounds like it's releated to an atmospheric CO2 model for the year 2020 with "seasonal adjustments" thrown in.)  The government says it's just a statistical fluke.  Here's the government's explanation of the Birth/Death model: CES Net Birth/Death Model

This link helps explain some of the government modeling in more detail:

Impact of business births and deaths in the payroll survey (PDF)

Not sure about this fellow, but he offers some more detailed analysis.  I visited the BLS web site, and all I can say is, gerbils must have come up with the model.  The results and historical data for the B/D model is all over the map.  Good luck believing the results.

May Employment Report Not Believable

Benjamin Disraeli, where are you when we need you?

Comments are closed

Powered by BlogEngine.NET 1.6.0.0
Theme by Mads Kristensen | Modified by Mooglegiant

Disclaimer

This blog represents my personal hobby, observations and views. It does not represent the views of my employer, clients, especially my wife, children, in-laws, clergy, the dog, the cats or my daughter's horse. In fact, I am not even sure it represents my views when I take the time to reread postings.

© Copyright 2008-2011